Administrative Arbitration: Conceptual Foundations, Scope, Procedures and the Protection of the Public Interest
The increasing complexity of public administration, the expansion of public-private partnerships, and the growing reliance on contractual arrangements between public authorities and private entities have intensified the need for effective mechanisms for resolving disputes involving public bodies. In this context, arbitration has emerged as a potentially valuable alternative to conventional judicial proceedings, particularly in disputes arising from public contracts, infrastructure projects, public procurement, and commercial activities undertaken by governmental entities. Nevertheless, the use of arbitration in the administrative sphere raises distinctive legal questions that cannot be addressed solely by reference to the principles governing ordinary commercial arbitration.
This article examines the conceptual foundations, legal nature, scope, and procedural framework of administrative arbitration, with particular emphasis on the tension between arbitral autonomy and the requirements of public law. It argues that the involvement of a public authority in a dispute does not, by itself, determine whether that dispute is arbitrable. Rather, arbitrability must be assessed by reference to the nature of the legal relationship, the subject matter of the dispute, the statutory powers of the public authority, and the public interests implicated in its resolution. The article further distinguishes between disputes concerning the contractual rights and financial obligations of public authorities, which may generally be suitable for arbitration subject to applicable law, and disputes concerning the exercise of sovereign regulatory powers, the validity of administrative acts, or matters reserved to public courts by legislation.
Adopting a comparative legal approach, the article examines the English arbitration framework, particularly the Arbitration Act 1996 as amended by the Arbitration Act 2025, the United States framework governing public contract disputes, and the international standards reflected in the UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration and the 1958 New York Convention. It demonstrates that although arbitration can promote efficiency, technical expertise, procedural flexibility, and commercial certainty, its use in public disputes requires safeguards concerning consent, impartiality, transparency, jurisdiction, procedural fairness, and judicial supervision.
The article concludes that administrative arbitration should not be understood as a substitute for administrative justice or judicial review. Instead, it should be conceptualized as a complementary dispute-resolution mechanism whose legitimacy depends on maintaining a clear distinction between arbitrable private or contractual interests and non-delegable public-law responsibilities. A balanced legal framework can therefore reconcile the advantages of arbitration with the fundamental requirements of legality, accountability, and the protection of the public interest.
Keywords: Administrative Arbitration; Public Law; Arbitrability; Public Contracts; Public Authorities; Alternative Dispute Resolution; Public Interest; Judicial Review; Administrative Justice.